Category

Criteria and Management

I

A benign simple cyst with a hairline-thin wall that does not contain septa, calcifications, or solid components; it has water attenuation and does not enhance; no intervention  is needed

II

A benign cystic lesion that may contain a few hairline-thin septa in which perceived  (not measurable) enhancement may be appreciated; fine calcification or a short segment of slightly thickened calcification may be present in the wall or septa; uniformly high-attenuating lesion (<3cm) that are sharply marginated and do not enhance are included in this group; no intervention is needed

IIF†

Cysts may contain multiple hairline-thin septa; perceived (not measurable)  enhancement of a hairline-thin smooth septum or wall can be identified; there may be minimal thickening of wall or septa, which may contain calcification that may be thick and nodular, but no measurable contrast enhancement is present (45); there are no enhancing soft-tissue components; totally intrarenal nonenhancing high-attenuating renal lesions (>3cm) are also included in this category; these lesions are generally well marginated;  they are thought to be benign but need follow-up to prove their benignity by showing stability (46)*                                                                                                         

III

Cystic masses with thickenend irregular or smooth walls or septa and in which measurable enhancement is present; these masses need surgical intervention in most cases, as neoplasm cannot be excluded; this category includes complicated

   hemorrhagic or infected cysts, multilocular cystic nephroma, and cystic neoplasms; these lesions need histologic diagnosis, as even gross observation by the urologist at surgery or the pathologist at gross pathologic evaluation is frequently indeterminate

IV

Clearly malignant cystic masses that can have all of the criteria of category III but  also contain distinct enhancing soft-tissue components independent of the wall or septa; these masses are clearly malignant and need to be removed

 

 

*Perceived enhancement refers to enhancement of hairline-thin or minimally thickened walls or septa  that can be visually appreciated when comparing unenhanced and contrast-enhanced CT images  side-by-side and on subtracted MR imaging datasets. This “enhancement” occurs in hairline-thin or smooth minimally thickened septa/walls and, therefore, cannot be measured or quantified. The authors  believe tiny capillaries supply blood (and contrast material) to these septa/walls, which are appreciated  because of higher doses of intravenous contrast material and thinner CT and MR imaging sections.

 

†“F” indicates follow-up needed.

 

"Bosniak Criteria for Renal Masses"

    How I Do It: Evaluating Renal Masses

     Gary M. Israel, MD and Morton A. Bosniak, MD

     From Radiology 2005;236:441-450